Why this book is banned This book was banned for three reasons. The first reason this book was banned is because of the sexual content. The second reason Water for Elephants was banned is because of some of the violence that August causes, and the third reason due to the extensive use of swear words.

Why was Water for Elephants banned?

Why this book is banned This book was banned for three reasons. The first reason this book was banned is because of the sexual content. The second reason Water for Elephants was banned is because of some of the violence that August causes, and the third reason due to the extensive use of swear words.

Is Water for Elephants a musical?

Circus-Set Love Story “Water for Elephants” Will Be Adapted Into Broadway Musical. “Water for Elephants,” the best-selling romantic novel about forbidden love in a traveling circus, will be adapted into a Broadway musical, producers announced Jan. 26.

What is the theme of Water for Elephants?

The theme of love is hard to miss, despite all the circus cruelties. Young Jacob falls instantly in love with Marlena, the trick horse rider. Later Marlena works with Rosie, the elephant, with whom both Jacob and Marlena fall in love.

Is water for the elephants a true story?

Though the characters never feel fully fleshed out, the novel works as an unlikely fairy tale, filled with vivid details (many, Gruen has said, drawn from real life) about the day-to-day operations of a gimcrack Depression-era Most Spectacular Show on Earth.

What circus is Water for Elephants based on?

Marlena and Jacob leave, taking with them a number of the circus animals including Rosie, Queenie, and Marlena’s horses. Jacob and Marlena begin their life together by joining the Ringling Bros. Circus.

Why is it called Water for Elephants?

The title, Water for Elephants, is almost a little inside joke with the reader… … To prove his point, McGuinty says that he “used to carry water for the elephants” (1.40). Those who don’t know about circuses take McGuinty at his word, but Jacob knows better: you can’t carry water for elephants.

Is Water for Elephants depressing?

Sara Gruen’s arresting new novel, “Water for Elephants,” explores similar subject matter — the pathetic grandeur of the Depression-era circus. And like Browning, Gruen infuses her audacious material with a surprisingly uplifting strain of sentimentality.

Is Rosie a real elephant in Water for Elephants?

A 42-year-old Asian elephant named Tai — most recently known for the role of Rosie in Fox’s Water for Elephants — was abused by its trainers in 2005, according to Animal Defenders International. … This poor elephant was trained to do the very tricks you see in the film by being given electric shocks.”

Who dies in Water for Elephants?

One night, Jacob attempts to kill August but chickens out. While he’s off doing that, several people are thrown out of the circus – they are literally thrown off the train. Both Walter and Camel are killed, and Jacob knows he was a target, too.

Article first time published on

Why is Water for Elephants Rated PG 13?

Water For Elephants is rated PG-13 by the MPAA for moments of intense violence and sexual content. Violence: A young man must identify the dead bodies of his parents after a car accident.

Is Water for Elephants a good book?

5.0 out of 5 stars Great book! The story Water for Elephants was beautifully told in the perspectives of teenage Jacob Jankowski on his adventure with the circus and dealing with grief, and 90 year Jacob, alone and forgotten in a nursing home with little patience for the people around him.

Did Reese Witherspoon ride the elephant?

For her latest role, Reese Witherspoon learned to ride an elephant. But, as Jonathan Van Meter discovers, that’s nothing compared to balancing fame and family. “I’ve always been a little bit of a tomboy,” says Witherspoon, with her Water for Elephants costar Tai.

What is the diagnosis of Marlena's horse?

Finally, Marlena brings out the horse Jacob is supposed to look at, Silver Star. Jacob can immediately tell that the horse is in really bad shape. Jacob examines Silver Star and gives his diagnosis: the horse’s feet are in major trouble and it may be too late to do anything about it.

Is Water for Elephants movie like the book?

The movie Water For Elephants stays close to Sara Gruen’s beloved book — particularly with the 1930’s circus memories section. The only place the movie veers from the original is in its details of the older, current Jacob. In the book, Jacob’s narration takes place in his own mind.

What happens in the prologue of Water for Elephants?

By Sara Gruen The narrator and some other circus folk are hanging out in the food joint while the show is on. … Since these men are out in the food joint, they don’t know yet what’s happening. Chaos ensues. A guy named Diamond Joe comes by, calling the narrator Jacob, and saying that all the circus animals are loose.

What happens at the end of the book Water for Elephants?

He closes the narrative on a happy note, explaining that he and Marlena finally got to be together after August died. They adopted Rosie and a bunch of other circus animals, and they made plans to join an even better circus. … And they’ve got a baby on the way – so in a way, their story ends with a new life.

Did Reese Witherspoon and Robert Pattinson get in Water for Elephants?

During her acceptance speech, Witherspoon retorted that Pattinson should have declared himself the “best motherf—– in Hollywood.” But it was obvious that their friendship went deeper. Almost a year after “Water for Elephants” was released, Witherspoon was still raving about Pattinson.

What is the age difference between Reese Witherspoon and Robert Pattinson?

Twilight star Robert Pattinson, 24, plays Jacob Jankowski – an orphaned veterinary student who is put in charge of a circus. There he meets Marlena, played by Witherspoon, the beautiful star of the equestrian act. Despite the age gap between Robert and Reese, 34, they play lovers in the film.

Is the elephant in saving flora real?

PETA condemns film company FJ Productions for its use of a live elephant in the movie Saving Flora, which is now showing in cinemas in the Philippines. … Ironically, in real life, Tai—the elephant used in the film—has been subjected to the same abusive training methods used in circuses.

Did they hurt the elephant in Water for Elephants?

No Animals Were Harmed During The Filming of Water For Elephants.

Is there animal cruelty in Water for Elephants?

Water for Elephants is a romantic drama about a circus vet set in the depression era and stars Reese Witherspoon and Christoph Waltz alongside Pattinson. It contains fictional scenes of animal cruelty and shows animals performing various tricks.

What happened to Walter in Water for Elephants?

In the end Walter doesn’t receive the same protection from Jacob. Jacob chooses to go after August, using Walter’s knife, at the exact moment when circus toughs come to their quarters to red-light them all (throw them off the train). He leaves Walter and Camel behind, alone and defenseless.

Where did the elephant come from in Water for Elephants?

SpeciesAsian elephantHeight269 cm (8 ft 10 in) (8′ 10″)Official site (Archived)

What year is Water for Elephants set in?

Set in the 1930s, a former veterinary student takes a job in a travelling circus and falls in love with the ringmaster’s wife. Set in the 1930s, a former veterinary student takes a job in a travelling circus and falls in love with the ringmaster’s wife.

What does Uncle Al want Rosie to do during the show?

Clive shows up among the men working in the menagerie and tells everyone to stay clear of August, who is in a terrible mood because Uncle Al wants August to put Rosie the elephant in the show’s parade. … Marlena is called to mount the elephant, and all the performers get ready to make their appearances.

Is Water for Elephants for kids?

Parents need to know that this romantic drama based on Sara Gruen’s best-selling novel features some disturbing scenes of domestic abuse, animal cruelty, and other violence.